Does the preliminary inquiry judge properly frame the case as circumstantial in nature?

Ontario, Canada

The following excerpt is from R. v Allison, 2016 ONSC 3073 (CanLII):

The preliminary inquiry judge properly framed the case as circumstantial in nature. Citing United States of America v. Sheppard (1977), 1976 CanLII 8 (SCC), 30 C.C.C. (2d) 424 (S.C.C.), he said he was tasked with deciding whether there is “any evidence upon which a reasonable jury properly instructed could, not would, convict?” He also acknowledged that, “It is not for me…to weigh the evidence or make any assessment as to the reliability/credibility of witnesses.” Importantly, the preliminary inquiry judge said, “I am also aware of the law that any inference that can be drawn must be drawn in favour of the Crown and it is not for me to weigh the various inferences that can be drawn at the preliminary hearing stage.”

Other Questions

In considering his role as a preliminary inquiry judge, what is the proper approach to assess all of the evidence at the preliminary inquiry? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for a preliminary inquiry judge to call upon an accused to plead to an absolute jurisdiction or summary conviction offence? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the role of a preliminary inquiry judge in determining guilt? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a preliminary inquiry judge commit an accused to trial where there is no evidence on the essential element of the charge? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the “legal test” used by the preliminary inquiry judge? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the appropriate test for a preliminary inquiry judge to commit an applicant to trial? (Ontario, Canada)
Can a motion judge interfere with the analysis and conclusion of a judge's assessment of the nature of the expression? (Ontario, Canada)
Does a judge have the same powers as a justice conducting a preliminary inquiry under Part XVIII of the Criminal Code? (Ontario, Canada)
Are evidentiary rulings by the preliminary inquiry judge not jurisdictional errors? (Ontario, Canada)
What is the test for appellate judges to review a discretionary decision by a motions judge? (Ontario, Canada)

Alexi white

"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.