Can a municipality without a by-law prevent a town from making improvements to its roads?

Manitoba, Canada


The following excerpt is from Ducharme v. Winnipeg (City), 1979 CanLII 2686 (MB CA):

In the Croft v. Peterborough case, Macaulay, C.J.U.C., said at p. 45: I think the question must be, not whether it might have been authorized or legalized by a by-law, but whether it is illegal, or can be justified without one; and in considering such a question I do not think the power to sanction and direct improvements of the kind, when they infringe upon private rights through by-laws legally made, confers by implication the power to make them without by-laws. ... The plaintiff might remonstrate against a by-law while in the course of being passed, or he might appeal against it if illegal in its provisions: at all events, acting without it is not executing the powers imparted by the legislature in conformity with the forms and observances required. At p. 46 he said: I am not prepared to lay down any general rule touching the line of separation in matters of this kind, between cases in which a by-law may or may not be necessary. In my present impressions, cases of either kind may arise, according to the circumstances. Whatever is cast upon the defendants as executive duties, under the statutes, in relation to the maintenance or repair of the roads, or whatever is fairly included in those terms, they may do without a by-law: when not so, and it is only within their discretion in the exercise of their legislative powers, it would be otherwise.

Other Questions


Does a city have to enforce its own building bylaw against a person with knowledge that he is in contraven tion of the bylaw? (Manitoba, Canada)
Can a police officer enter a house and make an arrest without a warrant in a hot pursuit? (Manitoba, Canada)
Is there any case law where an umpire considered information of one party without the knowledge of the other party? (Manitoba, Canada)
Does a doctor owe a duty to the future child of a mother who is on a medication prescribed by her doctor to prevent her from having a seizure? (Manitoba, Canada)
What is the test for making a decision in a child protection case? (Manitoba, Canada)
What is the test for making out a discrimination claim under section 15 of the Charter? (Manitoba, Canada)
What is the test for setting aside an order of without notice? (Manitoba, Canada)
Can a simple contract creditor make an attack upon a chattel mortgage under The Bills of Sale and Chattel Mortgage Act? (Manitoba, Canada)
What is the common law duty of a municipal corporation to keep its highways free of nuisance? (Manitoba, Canada)
If an order is made without jurisdiction and rescinded by the Court of Appeal, is there a remedy for a motion to rescind it? (Manitoba, Canada)
X



Alexi white


"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.