Does a subsequent purchaser of the legal estate have to pay the full consideration of the purchase, even after the purchase was completed, if the subsequent purchaser has paid the entire amount of consideration, even though the previous purchaser had a prior equitable interest in the property?

Saskatchewan, Canada

The following excerpt is from Alexander v. Gesman, 1911 CanLII 103 (SK CA):

First, as in Tourville v. Naish, 3 Peere Williams 307; 24 E.R. 1077, where the subsequent purchaser, after the purchase but before the payment of the full consideration money, had notice of a previous incumbrance. In such case the money in his hands is affected by such notice, and he takes the estate subject to the prior incumbrance; if he, after such notice, pays the purchase money without discharging the incumbrance, and this is the case even where he has given a bond for the payment of the balance of the purchase money, because he would be entitled to relief in equity from the payment of his bond to the extent of the prior incumbrance; and secondly, in such cases as Allen v. Knight (1845), 15 L.J.Ch. 430, where the holder of the legal estate was a trustee for the person having the prior equitable interest, because, by taking a conveyance with notice of the trust, he himself becomes the trustee, and must not, to save himself, be guilty of a breach of trust.

Other Questions

When competing interest in a property is expressed in a caveat, can the first purchaser of the property, who filed a caveat at the same time as the second, have priority to the first? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a purchaser bound by his acceptance of title to a property when the purchaser has not yet completed the contract? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Can a property owner be held liable for failing to disclose to the purchaser that he had a water issue with his property? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the test for establishing that the trust of a legal estate, whether in one name or several, results to the man who advances the purchase-money? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Is a real estate agent's statement of intent to sell a real property not an offer to sell the real property valid? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Does a purchaser of a property have to give up possession of the property to make a repudiation effective? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What action does a mortgagee in purchasing the mortgaged property at a tax sale place him in the position of holding the title, which he subsequently procures, subject to the right of the mortgagor to redeem? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
What is the effect of an agreement where an agent is required to pay a commission to a potential buyer of a property if the property is purchased directly or indirectly? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
When a vendor contracts to sell to a purchaser an agreement for a lease and the purchaser subsequently repudiates the contract, can the vendor continue to exercise its right to exercise that right? (Saskatchewan, Canada)
Does the value of a jointly owned property have to be discounted because the wife’s sister has a joint interest in the property? (Saskatchewan, Canada)

Alexi white

"The most advanced legal research software ever built."

Trusted by top litigators from across North America.